Background: The quality of dermoscopic images is affected by lighting conditions, operator experience, and device calibration. Color constancy algorithms reduce this variability by making images appear as if they were acquired under the same conditions, allowing artificial intelligence (AI)-based methods to achieve better results. The impact of color constancy algorithms has not yet been evaluated from a clinical dermatologist's workflow point of view. Here we propose an in-depth investigation of the impact of an AI-based color constancy algorithm, called DermoCC-GAN, on the skin lesion diagnostic routine. Methods: Three dermatologists, with different experience levels, carried out two assignments. The clinical experts evaluated key parameters such as perceived image quality, lesion diagnosis, and diagnosis confidence. Results: When the DermoCC-GAN color constancy algorithm was applied, the dermoscopic images were perceived to be of better quality overall. An increase in classification performance was observed, reaching a maximum accuracy of 74.67% for a six-class classification task. Finally, the use of normalized images results in an increase in the level of self-confidence in the qualitative diagnostic routine. Conclusions: From the conducted analysis, it is evident that the impact of AI-based color constancy algorithms, such as DermoCC-GAN, is positive and brings qualitative benefits to the clinical practitioner.
Impact of artificial intelligence-based color constancy on dermoscopical assessment of skin lesions: A comparative study
Zavattaro, Elisa;Veronese, Federica;Tarantino, Vanessa;Savoia, Paola;
2023-01-01
Abstract
Background: The quality of dermoscopic images is affected by lighting conditions, operator experience, and device calibration. Color constancy algorithms reduce this variability by making images appear as if they were acquired under the same conditions, allowing artificial intelligence (AI)-based methods to achieve better results. The impact of color constancy algorithms has not yet been evaluated from a clinical dermatologist's workflow point of view. Here we propose an in-depth investigation of the impact of an AI-based color constancy algorithm, called DermoCC-GAN, on the skin lesion diagnostic routine. Methods: Three dermatologists, with different experience levels, carried out two assignments. The clinical experts evaluated key parameters such as perceived image quality, lesion diagnosis, and diagnosis confidence. Results: When the DermoCC-GAN color constancy algorithm was applied, the dermoscopic images were perceived to be of better quality overall. An increase in classification performance was observed, reaching a maximum accuracy of 74.67% for a six-class classification task. Finally, the use of normalized images results in an increase in the level of self-confidence in the qualitative diagnostic routine. Conclusions: From the conducted analysis, it is evident that the impact of AI-based color constancy algorithms, such as DermoCC-GAN, is positive and brings qualitative benefits to the clinical practitioner.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
